1989 Ashley Edmunds

1990 Lisa St Pierre

1991 Andra Chapman

1992 Mandy Blank

1993 Janell Perry

1994 Janice Baker

1995 Melissa Corbett

1996 Karen Digman

1997 Lisa Gutman

1998 Summer Bray

1999 Darla Roach

2000 Judy Summers

2001 Tanya Biggs

2002 Jessica Hougentogler

2003 Kristen Hellman

2004 Lisa Kauffman

2005 Cara Guyette

2006 Amber Reininger

2007 Kristen Curtis

2008 Jennafaye Holliday

2009 Ashley Clemens

2010 Marissa Fry

2011 Mercedez Ertle

2012 Kyndall Koenke

2013 Tiffany Jockers

2014 Cierra Brown

2015 Lily Wright

2016 Sara Beck

2017 Holly Herron

2018 Grace Hammon

2019 Samantha Merigliano

2020 Kennedy Gill

2021 Lydia Wilt

2022 Tiffany McCoy

2023 Ally Carpenter

2024 Audrey Goodin

2026 Lilly-Ann Stewart